Tag Archives: UAC

Excessive CPU Use on Win8.1 Redux

The changes I made to solve the “Immersive Shell” DCOM errors did clear up the System event log. However, the high CPU usage persisted so I did more digging. I eventually found several references to problems with a Windows Backup scheduled task and its sdclt.exe process. I started Resource Monitor and saw many instances of sdclt.exe. Some were running and many more were recently terminated. There is a scheduled task that is designed to notify the user that Windows Backup has not been configured. For some reason the sdclt.exe process is repeatedly restarted and this ends up using considerable system resources.

The fix is to go to the task and disable it. The task is located in the Task Scheduler under Microsoft -> Windows -> WindowsBackup and is called ConfigNotification. Select it and disable it. Unfortunately a reboot is necessary to actually get the incessant sdclt.exe restarting to stop.

I have not found an official Microsoft acknowledgement that this is a problem nor have I seen any postulations as to why sdclt.exe is behaving in this fashion. The only common thread is that it occurs on Win8.1. Was this scheduled task introduced in Win8.1 or were there changes made to it with the Win8.1 upgrade? As far as I can tell the high CPU usage started after I installed the 2013-12-13 Windows Updates but I’ve no idea what those updates may have changed.

Regardless, I have a hunch as to what’s going on. I am one of what is certainly a very small number of people who run with User Account Control turned off. A few people turn UAC off because they don’t want to be nagged about running programs with full admin privileges. My reasons are more pragmatic. I have a home (Documents) folder that is redirected to a UNC share. I also run Visual Studio with Administrator privilege because that is the only way to enable debugging. Unfortunately folder redirection does not play nicely with UAC. This was causing all sorts of weird errors in Visual Studio. Thus I turned UAC off. There is a major Win8/Win8.1 consequence to turning UAC off: modern apps won’t run. This didn’t seem to me like much of an issue because I couldn’t stand them anyway. The reason they won’t run is they are configured to only run in a partially trusted application domain. With UAC off you can only run managed code in full trust mode. I’m guessing that the Windows Backup notification was written in partial-trust managed code. If this is the case, it certainly won’t run with UAC turned off. Apparently running the system with UAC off is not part of the Microsoft test matrix.

This brings up an old beef of mine. Why doesn’t the redirector have better support for UAC? It is a total pain that a redirection made as ordinary (limited privilege) user can’t be accessed by that same user with a full local administrator token. I’m sure there is some use case that I’m being protected against but I can’t figure out what it is since the file system ACLs will still be applied. Yeah, I know I am in the extreme minority of power users who push the system to its limits. That’s the standard argument for not accommodating corner cases.

At any rate, I’m sure glad I got the CPU usage issue sorted out. Boy I can’t wait to see what surprises are in the next round of updates!