User on Mac can’t login to AD, but can login from Windows

For about a month, we’ve been struggling with a pesky problem which boils down to the above description. As the above description suggests, the password is known to the user and the account is functional.

Other details:

  • Many others could login from all the macs tried—just the one user was having problems
  • We ensured that different groups setup the macs to rule out some odd configuration decision
  • We tried a couple semi-obvious things, like changing the password and ensuring the length and use of special characters shouldn’t cause problems on a Mac
  • We also looked closely at the AD account itself to see if there was anything broken or odd about it
  • We also tried inspecting the Mac-side logs, but that didn’t lead anywhere—but admittedly, our Mac expertise may not have been deep enough.

None of these produced much of anything and we were starting to create very far-fetched theories, and approaching what we thought was an option of last resort—deleting and recreating the AD user (which we now know probably wouldn’t have worked).

Finally, via a fortunate circumstance, one of our team members discovered there was another account with a displayName value which matched the user’s samAccountName value. We manually changed the displayName value on that other account, and logons for the person from Macs now worked!

The connection between a displayName and what the Mac client calls the username may seem arbitrary, but there is a fairly straightforward explanation:

  • Apple’s Mac AD client takes the username field value supplied and does an AD query using what is called ‘ambiguous name resolution’ (or ANR). This is a query against a set of pre-defined set of naming attributes. It’s what Outlook uses when you do an Address Book query. The ANR set includes displayName. You can find the other AD attributes it includes via an internet search of ‘ambiguous name resolution’. That’s a little funny design decision, but given the broad set of circumstances Apple might find in various Active Directories, it’s pretty understandable.

We believe the following to be true but there is a little speculation on our part:

  • Apple’s Mac AD client then takes all results from that query and silently chooses one and tries to authenticate using that one. If it fails, it doesn’t try any others and raises an error. Assuming our speculation is correct, this is a really bad design decision on Apple’s part.

The takeaway is there is a known problem where if your samAccountName matches the displayName or sn of another UW NetID, you may have problems logging in from a Mac.

I have never heard anyone else share anything remotely like this, nor have I found anything on the internet which suggests someone else has previously traced this problem to this cause. So I thought I’d share.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Required
Required